ChatGPT reviews of nonexistent albums

I've been experimenting with ChatGPT, asking it to invent novels by some of my favorite writers and write a book description, or invent albums by this or that artist and write a review. Either ChatGPT is very fond of the words "haunting" and "labyrinth," or everything I like is haunting and labyrinthine. Here are a couple of my results for your amusement. 

Me: Invent King Crimson's next album and write a review of it.

ChatGPT: Album: "Eclipse of Time"

Review: King Crimson's highly anticipated new album, "Eclipse of Time," is a sonic tour de force that defies conventions and pushes the boundaries of progressive rock. With their signature blend of intricate compositions, unconventional time signatures, and masterful musicianship, the band delivers an immersive and mind-bending experience that leaves listeners spellbound.

From the opening notes of the title track, "Eclipse of Time," it becomes apparent that King Crimson has once again crafted a sonic journey like no other. The album's intricate layers of guitar, bass, and drums weave together in a tapestry of musical complexity. The band's virtuosity shines through, showcasing their ability to seamlessly transition from serene passages to thunderous eruptions of sound.

Throughout the album, King Crimson showcases their ability to create intricate and ever-evolving musical landscapes. Tracks like "The Shifting Sands" and "Mosaic of Illusions" transport listeners through a labyrinth of twisting melodies and unexpected rhythmic shifts, keeping them on the edge of their seats.

One of the standout moments on the album is the hauntingly beautiful ballad, "Shadowed Dreams." With its delicate acoustic guitar and emotionally charged vocals, the song showcases a more introspective side of King Crimson. It serves as a moment of respite amidst the album's sonic onslaught, allowing the listener to catch their breath before diving back into the intricate musical tapestry.

The production on "Eclipse of Time" is top-notch, capturing the raw energy and intricacies of the band's performances. Each instrument is meticulously balanced, allowing the listener to fully appreciate the nuances of the compositions. The album's rich soundscapes are further enhanced by the incorporation of atmospheric elements and carefully crafted sound effects, adding another layer of depth to the overall sonic experience.

As the album reaches its climactic finale with the epic track "Beyond the Veil," King Crimson pulls out all the stops, unleashing a whirlwind of musical virtuosity and intensity. The band's synergy is palpable as they navigate through complex time signatures and intricate instrumental interplay, leaving listeners in a state of awe and wonder.

"Eclipse of Time" is a testament to King Crimson's enduring legacy and their uncompromising commitment to pushing the boundaries of rock music. It is an album that rewards active listening and invites the audience to embark on a sonic adventure unlike any other. With its mesmerizing compositions, jaw-dropping musicianship, and unparalleled artistic vision, this album solidifies King Crimson's status as pioneers of progressive rock, reminding us once again why they continue to be revered as one of the most influential bands in the genre.

Me: Invent Bryan Ferry's next album and write a review of it.

ChatGPT: Album: "Ethereal Rhapsodies"

Review: Bryan Ferry's latest musical creation, "Ethereal Rhapsodies," is a sublime masterpiece that transcends boundaries and transports listeners to a realm of enchantment and introspection. With his velvety voice and unparalleled musicality, Ferry takes us on a captivating sonic journey through a tapestry of genres, blending elements of art rock, jazz, and electronic pop.

From the moment the first notes of the opening track, "Whispers in the Mist," grace our ears, it becomes evident that "Ethereal Rhapsodies" is a sonic exploration of otherworldly beauty. Ferry's vocals are ethereal and evocative, painting vivid images in the mind's eye. The lyrics, like poetry, weave intricate tales of love, longing, and the mysteries of the human experience.

The album showcases Ferry's remarkable ability to reinvent his sound while staying true to his distinctive style. Tracks like "Celestial Dreams" and "Melancholy Serenade" marry lush orchestration with electronic elements, creating a soundscape that is simultaneously nostalgic and futuristic. The fusion of acoustic and synthetic instruments adds layers of depth and texture, immersing the listener in a sonic landscape that feels both familiar and unknown.

One of the standout moments on the album is the haunting ballad, "Luminescent Lullaby." Ferry's tender vocals float above a delicate piano arrangement, painting a portrait of delicate emotions and quiet introspection. In contrast, "Celestial Groove" is a mesmerizing journey into the realms of funk and rhythm, with infectious beats and infectious energy that invites the listener to surrender to the dance floor.

"Ethereal Rhapsodies" is not only a testament to Ferry's musical genius but also a testament to his ability to curate a cohesive and captivating listening experience. The album flows seamlessly from one track to the next, creating a sense of unity while allowing each song to shine individually.

As the final notes of the closing track, "Echoes of Infinity," fade away, the listener is left with a feeling of awe and introspection. "Ethereal Rhapsodies" is a musical voyage that transcends time and space, inviting us to explore the depths of our own emotions and contemplate the vastness of the universe.

Bryan Ferry's "Ethereal Rhapsodies" is a true gem, showcasing his timeless artistry and unyielding creative spirit. It is an album that resonates with both longtime fans and newcomers alike, leaving an indelible mark on the musical landscape. With its ethereal melodies, heartfelt lyrics, and masterful production, this album solidifies Ferry's status as a true visionary in the world of music, reminding us why his musical legacy continues to captivate hearts and minds.

Comments

  • On another board, they have something called “NP: Make It Up” 
    which started a year ago where people come up with fictitious
    artists and titles, but I started expanding on the concept months ago
    by showing fake LP covers using AI (and sometimes, not using AI).
    It’s been fun.
  • edited June 2023
    Thanks @burntwoodfactors for the great idea!

    I couldn’t resist seeing what ChatGPT would do inventing a brand new album for that great early 70s Prog/Hard Rock band Captain Beyond. I also asked it to compose a song.

    Makes me want to get the band back together and make the album!



    Title: "Eternal Visions: Captain Beyond's Cosmic Odyssey"

    Review:
    Captain Beyond's newest album, "Eternal Visions: Captain Beyond's Cosmic Odyssey," propels listeners on a mind-bending musical voyage through a cosmic expanse. This legendary rock band's triumphant return showcases their unparalleled musicianship, innovative songwriting, and an unwavering dedication to pushing the boundaries of their sound.

    The album kicks off with the high-octane track, "Stellar Fury," a blazing fusion of blistering guitar riffs, thunderous drumming, and soaring vocals. It sets the stage for the sonic adventure that awaits, as Captain Beyond invites us to explore uncharted territories of sound.

    With tracks like "Celestial Echoes" and "Nebula's Embrace," the band masterfully creates a celestial atmosphere, immersing the listener in a cosmic dreamscape. Psychedelic guitar solos intertwine with ethereal keyboards, while the rhythm section propels the music forward with precision and power.

    Captain Beyond's versatility shines through in songs like "Time Warp Serenade," where they seamlessly blend elements of progressive rock, jazz fusion, and blues. The band's ability to effortlessly transition between intricate melodies and explosive improvisations showcases their musical prowess and chemistry.

    One of the standout tracks, "Interstellar Reverie," is an epic opus that encapsulates the album's essence. Clocking in at over ten minutes, it takes the listener on a sonic odyssey through dynamic shifts, mesmerizing instrumental passages, and thought-provoking lyrics. It's a testament to Captain Beyond's ability to create a captivating narrative within their music.

    Lastly, the album concludes with the hauntingly beautiful ballad, "Cosmic Lullaby." This introspective piece showcases the band's softer side, with delicate acoustic guitars and heartfelt vocals, leaving the listener with a sense of awe and reflection.

    In "Eternal Visions: Captain Beyond's Cosmic Odyssey," the band has created a musical masterpiece that transcends time and space. It's a testament to their enduring legacy as pioneers of rock music, capturing their signature sound while also pushing the boundaries of their sonic exploration. This album is a must-listen for fans and newcomers alike, a testament to Captain Beyond's unwavering commitment to musical innovation.

    Composition: 

    Title: "Celestial Ascendance"

    Verse 1:
    In the depths of the universe, a journey begins,
    Captain Beyond embarks on a cosmic hymn.
    Guitars aflame, drums thundering in the night,
    We're soaring through the stars, guided by their light.

    Chorus:
    Celestial ascendance, our spirits take flight,
    Lost in the vastness of eternal night.
    The music carries us, beyond time and space,
    In this cosmic odyssey, we find our place.

    Verse 2:
    Through nebulas we glide, a cosmic ballet,
    Captain Beyond's music lighting up the way.
    Keyboards shimmer like distant stars above,
    As the bassline resonates, connecting us with love.

    Chorus:
    Celestial ascendance, our spirits take flight,
    Lost in the vastness of eternal night.
    The music carries us, beyond time and space,
    In this cosmic odyssey, we find our place.

    Bridge:
    Guitar solos blaze like comets through the sky,
    The rhythm pulses, our hearts beat in reply.
    We're immersed in the sound, transcending reality,
    Captain Beyond leads us to our musical destiny.

    Chorus:
    Celestial ascendance, our spirits take flight,
    Lost in the vastness of eternal night.
    The music carries us, beyond time and space,
    In this cosmic odyssey, we find our place.

    Outro:
    As the song concludes, we return to the Earth,
    But the echoes of the voyage, forever in
  • edited June 2023
    This is a Captain Beyond album cover made up by using an AI image generator

     

    As compared with the original s/t album cover from 1972


  • edited June 2023
    This makes me curious what kind of corpus the AI is leaning on. These read more like promotional blurb than reviews. Unless the reviews are written by unconditional fans suffering from a surfeit of adjectives.
  • @Germanprof you make a good point. I tried ChatGPT on the obscure early 70s band Gnidrolog and it came up with a very similar result. The words “Cosmic” and “Odyssey” being particularly popular!
  • edited June 2023
    This makes me curious what kind of corpus the AI is leaning on. These read more like promotional blurb than reviews. Unless the reviews are written by unconditional fans suffering from a surfeit of adjectives.
    If the AI is pulling heavily from a musician's promo material, it's an approach, regrettably, that wouldn't differentiate AI much from that of some reviewers.

  • > @jonahpwll said:
    > If the AI is pulling heavily from a musician's promo material, it's an approach, regrettably, that wouldn't differentiate AI much from that of some reviewers.

    I asked it to invent an XTC album and write a negative review. Boy, did it get out the knives!

    Album: “Dissonant Whispers”

    Review:
    XTC’s latest album, “Dissonant Whispers,” is a disappointing and disjointed offering that falls far short of the band’s previous creative heights. It is an unfortunate departure from their signature sound and a misguided attempt at experimentation that ultimately fails to deliver a cohesive and engaging musical experience.

    From the onset, it becomes apparent that “Dissonant Whispers” lacks the catchy melodies and memorable hooks that XTC is known for. The songs meander aimlessly, lacking clear direction and failing to leave a lasting impression. Tracks like “Lost Harmonies” and “Broken Chords” feel uninspired, with melodies that fail to ignite any sense of excitement or emotional connection.

    Lyrically, the album also falls flat. The once-clever wordplay and insightful observations that characterized XTC’s songwriting are noticeably absent. Instead, the lyrics veer into clichéd territory, with generic and unmemorable phrases that fail to resonate. The lack of depth and substance in the songwriting further contributes to the overall mediocrity of the album.

    Musically, “Dissonant Whispers” feels disjointed and unfocused. The band’s experimentation with unconventional time signatures and discordant melodies comes across as forced and lacks the cohesion found in their earlier work. Rather than pushing the boundaries in an innovative and captivating way, the album feels more like a collection of disconnected musical ideas that never fully develop or find their footing.

    The production of the album is equally disappointing. The mix lacks clarity, with instruments often competing for space and drowning each other out. The sonic palette feels muddy and cluttered, failing to capture the nuances and intricacies that could have elevated the songs. The overall production quality feels rushed and lacking the attention to detail that XTC’s previous albums were known for.

    “Dissonant Whispers” is a misstep for XTC and a disheartening addition to their discography. It lacks the energy, coherence, and songwriting prowess that made their earlier albums so beloved. The album fails to capture the essence of what made XTC a standout band in the first place, leaving listeners longing for the brilliance of their past works.

    In conclusion, “Dissonant Whispers” is an unfortunate regression for XTC. It is an album that fails to deliver on the promise of their previous musical achievements, lacking the memorable melodies, insightful lyrics, and cohesive musicality that defined their legacy. For longtime fans, it is a disappointment, and for newcomers, it fails to provide a compelling introduction to the band’s vast musical catalog.
  • @peterfrederics what a great idea to get it to write a song. I’ll have to give it a try.
  • Asked ChatGPT to write a new xtc song. I supplied the title. Not bad, all things considered. Did it do research into Swindon? Did it invent the concrete cows? That’s my fave detail.

    “Swinging Swindon”

    (Verse 1)
    In a town named Swindon, where dreams wither away,
    Where the streets twist and turn, beneath cloudy gray.
    We're the jesters and monarchs of mocking despair,
    Welcome to this place where weather doesn't care.

    (Chorus)
    Swinging Swindon, where dreams refuse to soar,
    We're trapped in a bubble, like nightfall at the door.
    Swinging Swindon, where sarcasm is our guide,
    Through traffic circles and rain, we'll never subside.

    (Verse 2)
    The Magic Roundabout whirls us round and round,
    As we navigate our path through this puzzling town.
    The locals wear grins tainted with disillusionment,
    But we're all in on the game, in our own contentment.

    (Chorus)
    Swinging Swindon, where dreams refuse to soar,
    We're trapped in a bubble, like nightfall at the door.
    Swinging Swindon, where sarcasm is our guide,
    Through traffic circles and rain, we'll never subside.

    (Bridge)
    We'll jest at the concrete cows and the train display,
    Raise a glass to the Oasis, a melodic foray.
    We'll stroll through the Designer Outlet with grace,
    Unearthing bargains, all while donning a smirk on our face.

    (Verse 3)
    In Swindon, we're renowned for our railway heritage,
    But it's the peculiar charm that keeps us anchored in this age.
    We'll wander through the Magic Garden, enchantingly rare,
    And recount tales of Swindon, a town beyond compare.

    (Chorus)
    Swinging Swindon, where dreams refuse to soar,
    We're trapped in a bubble, like nightfall at the door.
    Swinging Swindon, where sarcasm is our guide,
    Through traffic circles and rain, we'll never subside.

    (Outro)
    So let's raise a glass to Swindon, our town of wit and cheer,
    Where clever banter lingers in the atmosphere.
    Swinging Swindon, eternally bound we'll be,
    A town that embraces irony, where joy is plain to see.
  • Well, I think it's pretty clear that XTC is going to need their own dedicated AI if these results are any indication — relying on info from Wikipedia and Discogs just isn't going to cut it. Still, in all fairness, who ever heard of a negative XTC review? The whole concept is flawed from the get-go.
Sign In or Register to comment.