Mtracks

edited December 2010 in General
So with The Wire shutting down, I looked at Mtracks. Any reason I shouldn't sign up? The jazz selection is thin, but I've found enough now to keep me busy for at least a few months. Someone on another thread mentioned its CBR (instead of VBR); should this stop me from joining?
Any other input from people who are members?

Comments

  • Jonah, I did a trial in Oct 09, and everything is LAME 3.96, ~200 VBR.
  • I was somewhat incorrect in my report. I got 3 albums there in October. The 2 more recent albums (Hauschka's Ferndorf and Nina Nastasia's Outlaster) were both VBR V2 which is ~190 kbps. The other (Roy Montgomery's Temple IV) was 192kbps CBR.
  • Okay, so there's some mtracks members here. Anything you want to warn me about before I join? Their downloader bad? Make sure not to hit the album button and go after individual tracks? Beware potholes? Anything?
  • I was barely able to use even my free tracks when I tried it a year ago.
  • I was barely able to use even my free tracks when I tried it a year ago.

    Meaning that you didn't have much to choose from or some other meaning?
  • My main concern with mTracks (aside from some suspect encoding) is that there wasn't much in the form of new releases from a number of labels there. Plus, clicking around showed at least one of their top 20 albums is already gone.

    While Limewire felt like eMusic a year or 2 before Sony came along and spoiled our fun, mTracks feels like eMusic 5 years before Sony. Maybe I'm wrong, but so far I've found too many artists there with blank pages.
  • Oh sorry, I wasn't trying to be mysterious. The selection really doesn't suit my taste. It was really hard finding anything I like.

    Also, I agree the number of new releases is very disappointing.
  • So here's my quick review from doing the trial.

    Selection: From my early searches, I'd say this leans more heavily toward finding solid electronic. For jazz there are some labels from Europe and Clean Feed, for those free jazz folks. There is not much here though, for having two million tracks. Signing up for 75, which I did, means you're willing to go DJ in record basement and find some hidden gems. They do at least let you differentiate between Signed and Unsigned, a basic free upload fest.

    Layout: Not much in terms of searching, and the only real path to new artists is to find some artists on there you dig and then go through similar artists search. Likewise, you can find a good label like Fat Cat Records or Kranky, both of which I enjoy.

    Price: This is actually significantly more expensive than the 27 cents they advertise and especially compared to the defunk Wire. Every track over ten minutes costs 2 credits. Lots of examples too of album pricing for few-tracked albums. Still, now that the Wire is audios, this is the best deal assuming you find music you dig.

    Downloading: Pain in the butt one at a time, you have to set up everything. Plus, two of my albums were tagged in Chinese. Not on the same level as Guvera, but a close second.

    Sound Quality: Mediocre VBR 1. In my book, VBR 0 Lame is significantly better on any quality cans and hardly takes up more space, so this is disappointing. And one of my dls was CBR 192, even more wretched.

    For free, I got Darkstar's North, Pan America's For Waiting, For Chasing, Polmo Polpo's Science of Breath, and Tanakh's Ardent Fevers.

    They can have my twenty bucks for so-called 75 downloads, but I can't promise anything after that. Except that I will be hoping for a new start-up to take pre-Sony eMu's place in the universe.
  • Just wanted to add a few more thoughts after four months of downloading. First, if you dig musical exploration, and you use the site not with a particular artist or album in mind, you're going to find some great music, including some of the artists being touted from Bandcamp on this site. The interface is still limited, I get annoyed that a third of my albums are tagged in Chinese, and they haven't once changed featured artists or any changes at all outside of which songs/albums are on the charts list.

    But I know this group is fairly adept at moving past those roadblocks, and I recommend the service. The great European jazz, American electronica, and Canadian alternative I've found at the site have easily made it worth the twenty bucks a month for an average of eight or nine albums, depending on your style of music.
  • I just went back for a month at 9.99 after doing the free trial late last year. The selection certainly seems to be improving; first time I tried it I was barely able to find enough I wanted to use up the trial; this time I've found enough for more than my 30 downloads. For me it still looks at the stage where I'll probably dip in and out for a month at a time to relive the pressure on my SFL. The selection seems to be moving in the right direction, though.
Sign In or Register to comment.